Collection: Best-Selling Dice Bags & Dice Trays

The 17 most popular dice bags and dice trays from GameFancy — ranked by sales across 7,200+ completed orders. These are the products customers buy most often, reorder, and recommend. Every item here earned its place through repeat purchases, not promotion.

Prices run from $21.70 to $61.00. Capacity runs from 100+ dice in the plush creature bags to 300+ dice in the six-pocket fabric organizers.

What made the bestseller list:

Mimic Chest Dice Bag — from $32.00. 300+ dice capacity, gabardine with cotton lining, six-pocket version available. The treasure chest with teeth — the monster that has been eating adventurers since 1977, now holding your dice. Our single most-requested design.

Galaxy Dice Bag — from $32.00 ($41.00 with 6 pockets). 300+ dice, cosmic print, square base that stands upright. The best-selling fabric bag in the shop and the design that matches every table.

Gothic Mothman Dice Bag — $46.00. 100+ dice, plush cryptid pouch. The most popular Mothman bag we make.

Mothman Dice Tray — $21.70. Collapsible snap-button tray, 5.5 × 5.5 in. Twice an Etsy bestseller, the most affordable item here, and the most gifted.

Goblin Plush Dice Bag — $46.00. 120+ dice, sculpted green fleece. The original dice goblin bag.

Octopus Dice Bag — from $32.00. 300+ dice, 6 pockets, ocean fantasy print. A consistent top seller since launch.

Rainbow Velvet Dice Bag — $41.00. 120+ dice across six colour-coded pockets. Built for Dungeon Masters sorting dice by monster, NPC, or damage type.

Custom Printed Dice Bag — $39.00 to $54.00. Send your own artwork and we print it on gabardine and sew a bag from it. 300+ dice capacity. Three versions: $39.00 with no pockets, $49.00 with six pockets, $54.00 with six rainbow colour-coded pockets. A matching custom-printed dice tray is available on the same listing for $32.00. The most personalised item in the shop.

Also on the list: Goblin Dice Bag (120+ dice, stands upright), Mothman ITA Dice Bag, Mothman Cryptid Dice Bag (300+ dice), Cryptid Mothman Dice Tray, D20 Dice Bag (300+ dice, 6 pockets), Mothman Aesthetic Dice Bag (300+ dice), Goblin Plush Dice Bag with waist strap, Goblin Plush Dice Bag (Ork gift), and Fish ITA Dice Bag.

Construction by type: plush bags in sculpted fleece (100–120+ dice), fabric bags in gabardine with 100% cotton lining and a square standing base (300+ dice), ITA bags with a clear vinyl display window, and dice trays with snap-button assembly that fold flat for travel.

Every bag is handmade in our Cherkasy, Ukraine studio.

Shipping: Gothic Mothman Dice Bag, Mothman Dice Tray, Goblin Plush Dice Bag and Fish ITA Dice Bag ship from our Miami, FL warehouse in 1–3 business days via DHL — domestic parcels, no customs. Everything else is made to order in Cherkasy: 2–3 business days to make, then 7–14 business days in transit, approx. 9–17 business days total.

Who shops this collection: The first-time customer who wants a safe choice — if thousands of players already bought it, it works. The person buying a DnD gift who does not know the recipient's taste and wants the most universally liked option. And the returning customer checking what is new at the top since their last order.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which dice bag should I buy first?

If you carry more than three dice sets, start with a six-pocket fabric bag — Galaxy, Octopus or D20, from $32.00, 300+ dice capacity. If you carry one or two sets and want something with character, take a plush bag — Goblin or Mothman, $46.00, 100–120+ dice.

What is the cheapest bestseller?

The Mothman Dice Tray at $21.70. It folds flat with snap buttons, measures 5.5 × 5.5 in, and ships from Miami in 1–3 business days. It is our most-gifted item.

How much does a custom printed dice bag cost?

$39.00 with no pockets, $49.00 with six pockets, and $54.00 with six rainbow colour-coded pockets. All three hold 300+ dice and carry your own artwork printed on gabardine. A matching custom dice tray is $32.00.

Which bestsellers arrive fastest in the US?

Gothic Mothman Dice Bag, Mothman Dice Tray, Goblin Plush Dice Bag and Fish ITA Dice Bag are stocked in Miami, FL and arrive in 1–3 business days via DHL with no customs to pay.

What is a mimic dice bag?

A mimic is a monster from Dungeons & Dragons that disguises itself as a treasure chest and bites anyone who opens it. Our Mimic Chest Dice Bag is a handmade chest-shaped pouch with teeth that holds 300+ dice — the joke and the storage in one object. From $32.00.